| Person | Type | Job | Role(s) |
|---|---|---|---|
 Griffin McElroy | Crew | Directing | Director |
 Justin McElroy | Crew | Directing | Director |
 Travis McElroy | Crew | Directing | Director |
 Lin-Manuel Miranda | Cast | Actor | Self |
 Mara Wilson | Cast | Actress | Self |
 Matt Chapman | Cast | Actor | Strong Bad (Voice) / Homestar Runner (Voice) |
 Melissa Fumero | Cast | Actress | Self |
 Felicia Day | Cast | Actress | Self |
 Rob Corddry | Cast | Actor | Self |
 Ben Schwartz | Cast | Actor | Self |
 Ron Funches | Cast | Actor | Self |
 Barbara Dunkelman | Cast | Actress | Self |
Griffin McElroy | Cast | Actor | Self |
Justin McElroy | Cast | Actor | Self / Chris Evergreen |
Travis McElroy | Cast | Actor | Self |
 Jeremiah Watkins | Cast | Self | |
 Erika Ishii | Cast | Self | |
 Clint McElroy | Cast | Actor | Santa Clause |
Dwight Slappe | Cast | Jesus Impersonator | |
Teresa Mcelroy | Cast | Self | |
Charlie McElroy | Cast | Self | |
Tommy Smirl | Cast | Self / Tabitha's Dad | |
Amanda Coleman | Cast | Self | |
 Rachel McElroy | Cast | Actress | Self |
Bebe McElroy | Cast | Self | |
 Krystina Arielle | Cast | Actress | Self |
Mary Smirl | Cast | Chris' Mom | |
 Rileigh Smirl | Cast | Self / Tabitha's Friend | |
Carol McElroy | Cast | Professor Clause | |
 Teylor Smirl | Cast | Self / Tabitha's Friend | |
Laser Malena-Webber | Cast | Self | |
Henry McElroy | Cast | Self | |
Aubrey Turner | Cast | Self | |
 Sydnee McElroy | Cast | Actress | Self / Tabitha Bigcity |
| Person | Type | Job | Role(s) |
