This entire show is such BS. After watching this documentary I started looking more into the case since the film was woefully one-sided. It was alarming to me that Brooke's family were not included in the documentary if this were the truth of what happened. And as it turns out, this documentary leaves out a lot of evidence against Herman that contradicts his claim of what happened. The family refused to be part of the documentary because the claim in the film is a lie and they did not want their words twisted to benefit him. Brooke's sister is petitioning to have the film removed from Hulu for supporting her sister's killer and making a mockery of her death.

This is not a shockingly sad story about the possible dangers of violent parasomnia. This is a PR stunt intended to frame Randy Herman as the poor kid who killed his best friend in his sleep and didn't know what he was doing so that he can make noise, get enough people on his side, and hopefully succeed in his push to have his conviction overturned (which he is currently fighting.)

Don't believe everything this documentary says because this is essentially Herman's defense argument in video form with dramatic pauses, bad acting, and sad music all intended to evoke emotion and make you feel sad for him. It is missing a plethora of evidence and information contradicting Herman's testimony and does not acknowledge the state's arguments against him or the Preston family's protest of the making of the documentary.